Mp3's get damaged on samba share

[daballiemo]

Hi guys (and girls),

After running 8.10 after some time now, decided to move my music collection to a samba share which is connected to the system.
Doning so I decided to also check (MP3Diag) and organize (EasyTag) my mp3's in the process. After I moved the first albums I noticed a kind of a clicking sound in the music. When rechecking the mp3's with MP3Diag it showed that the mp3's were damaged. Having multiple streams, multiple tags etc. So I deleted the mp3's, rebooted the system, made sure the samba share was online and let the system settle down.

Moved a couple of albums to the hybrid which did not cause the same problem. Moved albums to the share again and ended up with the same problem. Anybody seen this behaviour before? Anything I can change/test/prove/list?

PS: System that is driving the samba share is a kubuntu 9.10 system

[daballiemo]

Here's some more data:

1) Before putting on samba share:

Code: [Select]

************************* /home//01-Checking/Michael Jackson_History (Disc 1)_05_She`s Out Of My Life.mp3 ************************* memory: 260000; time: Mon Jan 18 20:42:23 2010
0x0: ID3V2 tag doesn't have an APIC frame (which is used to store images).
0x0: Id3V230Stream built.
0x600: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x600: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x600: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x600: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x600: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85401f: Not an MPEG frame. File too short.
0x600: MpegStream built.
enter checkLastFrameInMpegStream()
exit checkLastFrameInMpegStream()
0x600: No normalization undo information found. The song is probably not normalized by MP3Gain or a similar program. As a result, it may sound too loud or too quiet when compared to songs from other albums.

************************* current memory used by the whole program: 260004; memory used by the current data (might be very inaccurate): 4; time: Mon Jan 18 20:42:23 2010

2) After putting on Samba Share:

Code: [Select]

************************* /home/mp3test/public/data/audio/Michael Jackson_History (Disc 1)_05_She`s Out Of My Life.mp3 ************************* memory: 260180; time: Mon Jan 18 21:02:24 2010
0x0: ID3V2 tag doesn't have an APIC frame (which is used to store images).
0x0: Id3V230Stream built.
0x600: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x600: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x600: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x600: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x600: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x600: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85401f: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x600: MpegStream built.
enter checkLastFrameInMpegStream()
stream found at 0x85401f
exit checkLastFrameInMpegStream()
0x85401f: ID3V2 tag doesn't have an APIC frame (which is used to store images).
0x85401f: Id3V230Stream built.
0x85461f: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x85461f: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x85461f: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85461f: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x85461f: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85461f: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x85461f: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85461f: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x85461f: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85525d: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x85461f: Invalid MPEG stream. Stream has fewer than 10 frames.
stream found at 0x854a33
0x854a33: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x854a33: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x854a33: MpegStreamBase built.
0x854a33: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x854a33: MpegStreamBase built.
0x854a33: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x854a33: MpegStreamBase built.
0x854a33: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x854a33: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85525d: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x854a33: Invalid MPEG stream. Stream has fewer than 10 frames.
stream found at 0x854e48
0x854e48: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x854e48: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x854e48: MpegStreamBase built.
0x854e48: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x854e48: MpegStreamBase built.
0x854e48: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x854e48: MpegStreamBase built.
0x854e48: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x854e48: MpegStreamBase built.
0x85525d: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x854e48: Invalid MPEG stream. Stream has fewer than 10 frames.
stream found at 0x85503e
0x85503e: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x85503e: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x85503e: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x85503e: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x85503e: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x85503e: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x85503e: Not an Ape tag. Invalid header.
0x85503e: Id3V1Stream built.
0x8550be: ID3V2 tag doesn't have an APIC frame (which is used to store images).
0x8550be: Id3V230Stream built.
0x8556be: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x8556be: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x8556be: MpegStreamBase built.
0x8556be: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x8556be: MpegStreamBase built.
0x8556be: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x8556be: MpegStreamBase built.
0x8556be: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x8556be: MpegStreamBase built.
0x8562fb: Not an MPEG frame. File too short.
0x8556be: Invalid MPEG stream. Stream has fewer than 10 frames.
stream found at 0x855ad2
0x855ad2: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x855ad2: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x855ad2: MpegStreamBase built.
0x855ad2: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x855ad2: MpegStreamBase built.
0x855ad2: Not a Xing stream. Header not found.
0x855ad2: MpegStreamBase built.
0x855ad2: Not a VBRI stream. Header not found.
0x855ad2: MpegStreamBase built.
0x8562fb: Not an MPEG frame. File too short.
0x855ad2: Invalid MPEG stream. Stream has fewer than 10 frames.
stream found at 0x855ee7
0x855ee7: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x855ee7: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x8562fb: Not an MPEG frame. File too short.
stream found at 0x8560fc
0x8560fc: Invalid ID3V2.3.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x8560fc: Invalid ID3V2.4.0 tag. Invalid ID3V2 header.
0x8560fc: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x8560fc: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x8560fc: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x8560fc: Not an MPEG frame. Synch missing.
0x8560fc: Not an Ape tag. Invalid header.
0x8560fc: Id3V1Stream built.
0x85401f: Two ID3V2.3.0 tags found, but a file should have at most one of them.
0x8550be: Two ID3V2.3.0 tags found, but a file should have at most one of them.
0x8560fc: Two ID3V1 tags found, but a file should have at most one of them.
0x600: No normalization undo information found. The song is probably not normalized by MP3Gain or a similar program. As a result, it may sound too loud or too quiet when compared to songs from other albums.
0x855ee7: Broken stream found. Since other streams follow, it is possible that players and tools will have problems using the file. Removing the stream is recommended.
0x855ad2: Unknown stream found. Since other streams follow, it is possible that players and tools will have problems using the file. Removing the stream is recommended.

************************* current memory used by the whole program: 311168; memory used by the current data (might be very inaccurate): 51192; time: Mon Jan 18 21:02:25 2010


[daballiemo]

Ok, 2 steps further:

1) Build a brand new system (with a lot of help from Possy due to the myth avenard repo problems that have been fixed with the B2.5 installer)
2) Prepared one album with shiny new tags (MP3Diags only shows that the songs have not been normalized)
3) Put the folder with the files on the samba share
4) After about 10 minutes the files were scanned and again all mp3 tags went tits up :-(

UpdateMedialog: see attached file

[daballiemo]

As another test I removed the album on the share, and after sometime put it on the core. Turns out the core did not alter the mp3 tags out of a MP3 Diags perspective.

[daballiemo]

And the next steps:

Used tagtool to strip all tagging info. Then used MP3 Diags to add one mp3 tag (vs2.3) to each song. MP3 Diags shows only the "song not normalized" info . When putting it on the samba drive -> mp3 tags have been damaged again. MP3 Diag complaining about multiple stream, multiple vs 2.3 tags etc.

[KingCrab]

Hello daballiemo,

I have the same problem copying oggs to my share. Did you found a solution for this problem?

[daballiemo]

Nope,

as a measure I put my mp3 files directly on the core.