News:

Rule #1 - Be Patient - Rule #2 - Don't ask when, if you don't contribute - Rule #3 - You have coding skills - LinuxMCE's small brother is available: http://www.agocontrol.com

Main Menu

Xine not playing the correct audio channel. Solution?

Started by erasmix, March 25, 2008, 08:43:46 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

erasmix

Hello,

I have a few mkv files with both Chinese and English channels. I assume xine plays the default language, which is Chinese. However when I right click on the player and go to "Audio" -> "Channel" and select "eng", it continues to play in Chinese. After going mad for a few minutes, I decided to select "chi" and it finally decided to play in English  ??? I also installed VLC and tested. The Audio channels are correctly labeled "English" & "Chinese", and they are not crossed like on xine ("English" plays in English, and so on). Even more pleasant, VLC plays the English channel by default, not Chinese.

This definitely seems like a bug in xine, but even when/if gets fixed the best way around would be to have a Video Menu, like we have a DVD Menu inside the LinuxMCE interface. Do you guys agree?

Thanks,

Erasmo.

kir

Quote from: erasmix on March 25, 2008, 08:43:46 AM
the best way around would be to have a Video Menu, like we have a DVD Menu inside the LinuxMCE interface. Do you guys agree?

Yes :) There is mantis on this already: http://mantis.linuxmce.org/view.php?id=3836

Regarding this:
Quote from: erasmix on March 25, 2008, 08:43:46 AM
I have a few mkv files with both Chinese and English channels. I assume xine plays the default language, which is Chinese. However when I right click on the player and go to "Audio" -> "Channel" and select "eng", it continues to play in Chinese. After going mad for a few minutes, I decided to select "chi" and it finally decided to play in English  ???
Can you provide a sample file that has this error?

erasmix

#2
Awesome!!!  ;D I saw the change in Mantis. When is it expected out?

The file in question is 8G. I could provide you a torrent file though.

erasmix

UPDATE:

I've tested the latest version of XINE on my Fedora box (which is seems a cpl releases newer than linuxMCE's), and it plays as desired. English by default, and the audio channels point correctly to Chinese and English respectively. Therefore it seems the quickest fix would be to embed the latest version of XINE onto the next release.

Regards,

Erasmo.

kir

The next release (or beta) will have xine-lib 1.1.10.1 - this should be new enough for this :)