Two NICs, continued

[PetRose]

Hi folks
As a newbie, reading thru a lot of prereq's of MCE and especially the core component. I haven't found enough detail yet, on the subject of two nic's, although I understand its some sort of a requirement (at a certain level).
But, is it required that both of these nic's are CAT5/Ethernet wired ?
I have thought of using a spare PC with one builtin ETH nic (for Internal network), and supply a USB WiFi adapter for the External network via my WiFi Access Point (for which I disable DHCP).

Is this below the requirements of the MCE core ?

Thanks

[tschak909]

unfortunately, because often wireless cards have different network interface names than an ethernet card, the software will not be able to detect and set up a wireless card automatically, no matter if it's the internal or external card.

-Thom

[PetRose]

Thanks for clarifying

Would it be worthwhile to turn this over to a Request for Functional enhancement ?
I believe it will be a truely big enhancement that will remove the physical barrieres and hopefully catch a even bigger wave with the LMCE audience and potential users.

[colinjones]

BTW - you don't have to turn off your DHCP on your external network, just don't have any other DHCP servers on the dedicated LMCE internal network.

Thom - do you think you might be able to use a udev rule to force the NIC name to eth0?

[tschak909]

maybe.

-Thom

[Viking]

Hi,

I have also not yet found the Info why 2 NIC's are reccomended.
I suppose it is because you can then let the internet router stay as it is (using DHCP) and the MD's get their DHCP from the Core. But are there other reasons ?

I would like to only have one network in my house, so I don't see the reason for the Core having two network cards. If it did I would connect the outside network card to the Internet router and everything else to the internal switch.
With one network I would connect everything to the Internet router/switch and disable the DHCP server in the router. I am familiar with DHCP, PXE boot and TCP/IP so I am sure I can get along with that kind of system.

With one networkcard I would get a Virtual ETH0:1 where DHCP is running, right ? 

Thanks for any feedback

Greetings
Christian

[rodercot]

 I think to circumvent Thom's blood pressure rising higher than it is currently, this is an old post.

 I think the easiest way to combat these posts of not using the system as is requested or designed is to just ignore them or not respond. IT has been talked about and proven time and time again on the forums and it is getting REALLY OLD. If you do not want to use the system the way it is designed then do not expect HELP when it does not work out for you.

 Sorry if I seem harsh here, but do a search here or in the wiki and you will see why.  Do it the way it asks and you will have much less eventful installation.

 rgds,

 Dave

[colinjones]

Agreed, saying you can't find the info simply means you haven't done any searches. There are literally hundreds of posts and many wiki articles.

[Viking]

Hi,

OK, I am sorry - now I found it in the Wiki.  Hmm, must have been blind 
http://wiki.linuxmce.org/index.php/Network_Settings
http://wiki.linuxmce.org/index.php/Why_dual_network_cards%3F

The problem with searching in the forum is that you indeed get loads of answers and there I did not find the in-deep-answer for my question. Maybe I should have read them _all_ before asking or searched better in the Wiki. Sorry for that folks.

I do understand it is a pain in the a.. answering the same questions over and over again I have also seen this problem very offen in other forums ... And therefore I am allways searching first before asking.

But thanks for leading me to searching the wiki again

Greetings
Christian

[itspac]

unfortunately, because often wireless cards have different network interface names than an ethernet card, the software will not be able to detect and set up a wireless card automatically, no matter if it's the internal or external card.

-Thom

just an FYI.  If you use the cd version to install linuxmce, like I had to with my newest motherboard, and you have the wireless card setup and running on kubuntu first, Linuxmce will pick up the wireless card and use it,

I didnt think it would work, but it did for me. Took a wireless nic  named ra0 and allowed me to make it the external interface during the installation. It worked fine after linuxmce install.